Influence of skidding in two mechanized tillage
systems for quinoa cultivation
Influencia del patinaje en dos sistemas de labranza
mecanizada para el cultivo de quinua
Roque Orlando García-Zanabria
1
Abstract: The mechanized tillage systems of agricultural soils for the
cultivation of quinoa in the central Ecuadorian highlands are
influenced by several factors, among them: the skidding that occurs
in soil tillage, with different implements used both in conventional
tillage and in minimum or reduced tillage, in plowing, harrowing,
furrowing, which are executed for the cultivation of quinoa, without
considering the slope, humidity, soil compaction and the increase in
cost and time. The objective of the study was to determine the
percentage of skidding in sandy textured soils for quinoa cultivation,
with slope ranges from 5 to 12% with moisture contents from 13 to
18% under conventional and minimum or reduced tillage systems in
plowing, harrowing, furrowing, using disk plow, chisel plow, disk
harrow, furrower coupled to an agricultural tractor of 95 KW of power
with assisted traction.
Keywords: skidding, ploughing, compacting
Resumen: En los sistemas de labranza mecanizada de suelos
agrícolas para el cultivo de quinua en la sierra central ecuatoriana
influyen varios factores entre ellos: el patinaje que se produce en el
laboreo del suelo, con diferentes aperos utilizados tanto en labranza
convencional como en labranza mínima o reducida, en labores de
arada, rastrillada, surcada, que se ejecuta para el cultivo de quinua, sin
considerar la pendiente, humedad, compactación del suelo y el
incremento de costo y tiempo. El objetivo del estudio fue determinar
el porcentaje de patinaje en suelos de textura arenosa para cultivo de
quinua, con rangos de pendiente de 5 a 12% con contenidos de
humedad de 13 al 18% bajo sistemas de labranza convencional y
mínima o reducida en labores de arada, rastrillada, surcada, utilizando
arado de discos, arado cincel, rastra de discos, surcador acoplados a
un tractor agrícola de 95 KW de potencia con tracción asistida.
Palabras clave: patinaje, labranza, compactación
1
Ingeniero Agnomo. Magister en Educación e
Investigación educativa. Doctor en Ciencias
Ambientales, Docente Escuela Superior
Politécnica de Chimborazo
rogarcia@espoch.edu.ec
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9413-3204
Published
Instituto Tecnológico Superior Edwards
Deming. Quito Ecuador
Periodicity
January-March
Vol. 1, Num. 21, 2024
pp. 1-11
http://centrosuragraria.com/index.php/revista
Dates of receipt
Received: December 22, 2023
Approved: Febrary 12, 2024
Correspondence author
rogarcia@espoch.edu.ec
Creative Commons License
Creative Commons License, Attribution-
NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0
International.https://creativecommons.org/lice
nses/by-nc-sa/4.0/deed.es
Influence of skidding in two mechanized tillage systems for quinoa cultivation.
2
Introduction
In the central highlands of Ecuador, soil preparation for quinoa
cultivation is carried out by applying conventional and minimum tillage
systems, using different implements that cause soil compaction for
agricultural crops, with machinery traffic having the greatest impact.
The influence of agricultural machinery on compaction is expressed
through the action of: pressure on the soil, weight on the rolling
systems, number of passes, travel speed and slip; which act on the
prevailing conditions on the ground the state of compactness of the
plow layer; the slip should be between 5 and 15%, and when it exceeds
15% damage occurs on the soil surface, increases fuel consumption.
The available power is considerably reduced when wheel slip is below
the recommended minimum. The ideal slip percentage varies from 8 to
15 % depending on the type of tractor traction (Gómez-Calderón V.-M.
S.-Q., 2016).
When a volume of soil is subjected to the stresses caused by the traffic
of agricultural machinery and these exceed the internal resistance of the
soil, compaction occurs, which has a cumulative character. It extends
from the surface to the subsoil. Surface compaction originates up to a
depth of 0.3 m, in the arable layer, and subsoil or subsurface compaction
occurs at depths greater than the arable layer (Alakukku et al., 2003)
cited by (Omar González Cueto, 2010).
The effect of skidding on compaction is manifested through the increase
in the length of the contact area and by the shear stress on the soil.
Tractor skidding compacts only a thin layer of surface soil up to 0.05
m, its greatest effect is seen from 20 to 30% of skidding, decreasing the
pressure on the soil of the vehicle. With skidding higher than 30% the
volume density decreases because the wheel digs the soil and throws
back the soil, they recommend a maximum skidding of 10%, to avoid
damage to the surface layer and the subsoil due to the shear stress of the
tire (Omar González Cueto C. E., 2009).
It has been proven that surface compaction is produced by the pressure
in the wheel-soil contact zone, but subsurface compaction is produced
by the entire weight of the equipment (V. Gasso, 2013); therefore if the
weight of an axle does not exceed 49 kN, it will only compact the first
30 cm of the soil profile. (A. M. Terminiello, 2000) This is how the
April - June vol. 1. Num. 21 2024
3
traffic of the wheels of the equipment used under the RTF system
impacts soil compaction. This system consists of passing machinery
over the crop field, often intensively, where the decision of the sequence
and frequency of operations is made by the producer, causing soil
destructuring and reducing its effective porosity.
It has been indicated that in order to conserve the soil efficiently, the
number of passes of agricultural machinery over the field should be
reduced (B. P. Cadena, 2012). Hence the importance of an adequate
selection of equipment (in terms of topography, soil, crop and
machinery performance) to avoid repetitive passes of equipment over
the same work area with machinery unsuitable for the operating
conditions (M. Kroulík, 2011).
Under normal operating conditions of agricultural machinery, when
four-wheel drive is used, the power transmission at the rear wheel is
more efficient than at the front wheel, but the amount of power
developed by the rear axle is less than that at the front due to load
differences at the rear and front axles (J. M. Serrano, 2009).
Compaction affects crop development and production; the bulk density
of a sandy loam soil is between 1.5 to 1.7 g/cm3 USDA (2000).
Quinoa is an Andean crop of high nutritional value that is in high
demand in the domestic and international markets. The technology used
in cultivation varies from traditional to highly technical, with an
emphasis on soil conservation (Emilio Pinedo Taco, Alberto Marcial
Julca Otiniano, 2020).
The chisel plow is an equipment of massive use in agriculture, which
has come to satisfy the need to break and remove the soil, without
inverting it, at depths between 20 to 35 cm, the minimum or reduced
tillage system seeks to reduce soil loss, reduce compaction, conserve
moisture, reducing the number of passes, using vertical working
equipment such as the chisel plow, the chisel plow works at a speed of
4 to 6 km / hour (Jorge Riquelme S.).
The disc plow used in conventional tillage performs a horizontal cutting
and turning action of the soil and can work at a speed range of 5 to 8
km/hour; the disc harrow is a secondary work implement that allows
breaking up the soil and chopping stubble, it works at a speed of 5 to 10
km/hour depending on its type; the furrower has the purpose of tracing
Influence of skidding in two mechanized tillage systems for quinoa cultivation.
4
furrows and its working speed is 4 to 6 km/hour (JAIME ORTIZ-
CAÑAVATE PUIGMAURI, 2012).
Conventional or traditional tillage involves the intensive use of disc
implements such as harrows, rakes and polishers that seek to remove
the soil surface. The number of passes ranges from 4 to 8, which can
cause annual soil losses of 10 t/ha, compaction and soil degradation
(Colombiano, 2021).
Materials and methods
The research was carried out in the field in the community of Tunshi in
the canton of Riobamba, province of Chimborazo, Ecuador, located at
the following coordinates: latitude 1o 45'20''N, longitude 78o 38'20'',
altitude 2829m.a.s.l. (Figure 1). m (figure 1) with an average annual
temperature of 15oC, average rainfall of 650 mm, relative humidity of
68%, the soil belongs to the Inceptisol order with slightly undulating
topography, slope of 5 to 12%, sandy loam texture, humidity of 5 to
18%, the previous crops were corn, peas, barley, potato. A 10000m2 lot
was used in DBCA design with 3 replications in which conventional
tillage systems were applied with disc plow, disc harrow and furrower
and in minimum tillage with chisel plow and furrower coupled to an
agricultural tractor of 95 Hp power assisted traction (figure 2). The
travel time, the travel distance in 10 turns of the driving wheel, the
percentage of skidding was calculated for the two tillage systems with
each implement. In addition, the resistance to cutting was determined
with the penetro meter and the infiltration velocity using the double ring
meter infiltrator.
The following formula was used to determine the slip:
% Skid = (Dsc _ Dcc)/Dsc x 100 (1) where : Dsc = unloaded
displacement in (m);
Dcc = displacement with load (m)
April - June vol. 1. Num. 21 2024
5
The displacement is considered as 10 turns of the driving wheel.
Figure 1. Map of Tunshi community
Figure 2. Equipment and implements used in the investigation
Influence of skidding in two mechanized tillage systems for quinoa cultivation.
6
3. Result
In mechanized soil preparation for quinoa cultivation in the central
highlands of Ecuador, conventional tillage and minimum tillage
systems are used with different types of implements and number of
passes in the same plot in each case, as shown in Table 1, and Table 2
shows the percentage of skidding that occurs in the drive wheels and in
the steered wheels during the 10 turns of the same in each plot.
Table 1. Tillage systems and implements used
Sistemas de labranza
Labranza convencional
Labranza mínima
Table 2. Percentage of skidding on drive and steer wheels for each
implement, speed and working depth
Sistema de
labranza
Apero
% Patinaje
rueda
motriz
%
patinaje
rueda
directriz
Velocidad
Trabajo
Km/h
Profundidad
de labor (m)
Arado de
discos (4)
7,44 a 15,9
6,43 a 9,5
6
0,30
April - June vol. 1. Num. 21 2024
7
Labranza
convencional
Rastra de
disco de tiro
excéntrico
(16)
7,63 a
12,89
5,78 a 9,5
8
0,15
Surcador
trisurco
7,44 a 9,89
6,19 a 6,9
5
0,25
Labranza
mínima
Arado
cincel
5,45 a 7
3,2 a 3,7
5
0,30
Surcador
trisurco
3,1 a 4,3
2,2 a 3,5
5
0,25
The disk plow used in the conventional tillage system presents a slip
percentage of 15.9% in the driving wheel, being the primary tillage
implement that in the present trial has the highest value compared to the
chisel plow used in minimum tillage, which presents 7% slip; the other
implements for complementary tillage present lower values as can be
seen in Table 2.
Soil compaction occurs when pressure or load is applied to the soil
surface, as a result of trampling by animals and people, inadequate use
of equipment such as tractors, especially when the soil is wet,
depending on the tillage system, the implement applied in each task,
which produces different percentages of slippage.
The percentage of skidding of the driving wheel in soils of sandy to
sandy loam texture should not exceed 15% when this happens the
traction is inefficient, soil moisture and shear strength in Kpa in soils of
the Tunshi community, presents statistical differences for tillage
systems with an average of 8.93 Kpa and a Coefficient of Variation of
5.78%.
This is explained by the action of the horizontal rototilling implements
caused by implements such as the disk plow, disk harrow that influence
the first 0.25 m of the soil, used in conventional tillage; while the
application of vertical rototilling implements such as the chisel plow,
allows a good aeration and loosening of the soil at greater depth, which
is achieved with alternative tillage, preserving the agricultural aptitude
of the soil, avoiding degradation, which in the end can be manifested in
the crop yield.
Influence of skidding in two mechanized tillage systems for quinoa cultivation.
8
The tillage system influences soil compaction to the extent of the
intensity of tillage, this compaction in turn influences the root growth
of quinoa, the development of the plant, and finally the yield.
Penetration resistance is a good index to evaluate problems of
restriction in the root development of plants, due to the presence of
compacted layers and/or low porosity. Soil penetrability is a measure
of the ease with which an object can be introduced into the soil, i.e., the
mechanical resistance of the soil to lateral expansion and shearing
produced by the object.
This resistance is not a particular property of the material, but is the sum
of the effects of different characteristics and properties, such as bulk
density, moisture content, resistance to penetration and shear, which in
turn, are a consequence of the particle size distribution, structure, and
mineral and organic composition present in the soil.
Compaction causes changes by altering physical properties such as
porosity and bulk density, which in turn reduces the rate of water
infiltration and the availability of air for root growth. The resistance of
a soil to penetration by a probing instrument is an integrated index of
soil compaction, moisture content, texture and clay type. It is an index
of soil resistance. It is a determination involving soil consistency and
structure. The instrument used to determine it is called penetrograph or
penetrometer and measures the force needed to penetrate the soil with
a probe.
Figure 1. Percentage of skidding as a function of the aperture
4. Conclusions
April - June vol. 1. Num. 21 2024
9
The tillage system and the implement used in soil preparation for quinoa
cultivation influence the percentage of slippage that occurs, above the
limit of 15%, which affects the agricultural suitability and quality of the
soil in the Tunshi community, affecting its physical properties; while
the application of minimum tillage, with the chisel plow, favors the
conservation of the agricultural suitability of the soil.
The use of disc implements in conventional tillage system can change
the soil structure after some time, due to the effect of the horizontal cut
with inversion of the soil that is produced.
The application of minimum tillage system with the use of chisel plow
tends to conserve the physical properties of the soil such as: bulk
density, porosity, soil moisture, infiltration rate, temperature, while the
use of implements under the conventional system alters the values in
the case of this sandy loam soil, moving away from ideal conditions for
cultivation with the consequent low yield of quinoa crop.
References
Håkansson. (1990). Un método para caracterizar el estado de
compacidad de la capa de arado. Investigación de suelos y
labranza , 16 (1 y 2), 105 - 120.
Koolen, A. J. (1974). Un método para determinar la compactibilidad
del suelo. Revista de investigación en ingeniería agrícola , 19
(3), 271-278.
Gómez-Calderón, V.-M. K. (24-28 de octubre de 2016). PATINAJE
DE TRACTOR CON DOS IMPLEMENTOS DE LABRANZA
EN DOS TIPOS DE SUELO EN COSTA RICA. PATINAJE DE
TRACTOR CON DOS IMPLEMENTOS DE LABRANZA EN
DOS TIPOS DE SUELO EN COSTA RICA . Quito, Picincha,
Ecuador: Sociedad Ecuatoriana de la Ciencia del Suelo.
Gómez-Calderón, V.-M. S.-Q. (24 -28 de Octubre de 2016).
PATINAJE DE TRACTOR CON DOS IMPLEMENTOS DE
LABRANZA EN DOS TIPOS DE SUELO EN COSTA RICA.
PATINAJE DE TRACTOR CON DOS IMPLEMENTOS DE
LABRANZA EN DOS TIPOS DE SUELO EN COSTA RICA .
Quito, Pichincha, Ecuador: Sociedad ecuatoriana de la Ciencia
del suelo.
Influence of skidding in two mechanized tillage systems for quinoa cultivation.
10
Omar González Cueto, M. H. (2010). Modelación de la compactación
del suelo. Modelación de la compactación del suelo . Villa Clara
, Santa Clara, Cuba: Feijoo.
Omar González Cueto1, C. E. (2009). Análisis de los factores que
provocan compactación del suelo agrícola. Revista Ciencias
Técnicas Agropecuarias , 57-63.
Omar González Cueto, C. E. (2009). Análisis de los factores que
provocan compactación del suelo agrícola. Ciencias Técnicas
Agropecuarias, , 18 (2), 57 - 63.
V. Gasso, C. a. (2013). Controlled traffic farming: A review of the
environmental impacts. Eur. J. Agron , 48, 66 -73.
A. M. Terminiello, R. H. (2000). Compactación inducida por el tránsito
vehicular sobre un suelo en producción hortícola. Bras. Eng.
Agrícola e Ambient , 4 (2), 290 -293.
J. M. Serrano, J. O. (2009). The effect of liquid ballast and tyre inflation
pressure on tractor performance. Biosyst. Eng., , 102 (1), 51 -62.
B. P. Cadena, D. E. (2012). Efecto de cinco sistemas de labranza, en la
erosión de un suelo vitric haplustand, bajo cultivo de papa
(Solanum tuberosum L. Ciencias Agrícolas, , 29 (2), 116 -128.
M. Kroulík, Z. K. (2011). Procedures of soil farming allowing reduction
of compaction. Precision Agriculture, , 12 (3), 317 -333.
Emilio Pinedo Taco, L. R. (12 de junio de 2020). Sostenibilidad
ambiental de la producción de quinua (Chenopodium quinoa
Willd.) en los valles interandinos del Perú. Ciencia &
Tecnología agropecuaria .
Emilio Pinedo Taco, L. R. (2020). Alberto Marcial Julca Otiniano.
Ciencia & Tecnnología Agropecuaria , 21 (2).
Colombiano, R. d. (15 de febrero de 2021). Estos son los tipos de
labranza que usted puede utilizar en su predio. Estos son los
tipos de labranza que usted puede utilizar en su predio . Bogota,
Colombia.
April - June vol. 1. Num. 21 2024
11
Jorge Riquelme S., J. C. EQUIPOS DE LABRANZA PARA EL
MANEJO DE SUELOS. INIA. Boletín INIA, Nº 207.
JAIME ORTIZ-CAÑAVATE PUIGMAURI, P. B. (2012). Las
máquinas agrícolas y su aplicación. MADRID, ESPAÑA:
MUNDI-PRENSA.