victor.verdezotov@ug.edu.ec
Characterization of cocoa (theobroma cacao, l.) producing farms in the canton of
yaguachi, Guayas Province
Caracterización de fincas productoras de cacao (theobroma cacao, l.) Nacional agroforestales
renovadas, en el cantón yaguachi, Provincia Guayas
Victor Hugo Verdezoto Vargas
Mg. Sustainable Management of Natural Resources,
University of Guayaquil, Ecuador.
victor.verdezotov@ug.edu.ec, https://orcid.org/0000-
0002-6005-396X
Sergio Leonardo Pino Peralta
Ph.D. Environmental Sciences, University of Guayaquil,
Ecuador. sergio.pinop@ug.edu.ec ,
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9254-1597
Cristian Fabian Verdezoto Castillo
B.S. Marketing, ESPOCH, Ecuador.
cristian.verdezoto@espoch.edu.ec, https://orcid.org/0000-
0002-2153-4699
Abstract
There is scarce information on the area under cocoa cultivation and inventory of species in renewed
agroforestry farms in the Union de Organizaciones Campesinas Cacaoteras del Ecuador (UNOCACE);
the purpose of this research was to georeference the area of dynamic agroforestry systems in national
cocoa (Theobroma cacao L) producing farms and inventory the flora. The georeferenced coordinate
method was used to determine the area of the farm; and, the global positioning system (GPS), to locate
the species that make up the agroforestry system, using for this case the KoboCollect and GPS Status
applications, downloaded on a smart mobile device (cell phone). Between 2016 and 2017, the small
producers of the "El Deseo" precinct, installed 15 farms, resulting in a total of 11.8873 ha of dynamic
agroforestry systems, being the area range from 0.3 to 2.0 hectares. The agroforestry systems evaluated,
present different results according to each individual, species and family that compose it. In these
agroforestry systems, it is recommended to complement with cocoa (Theobroma cacao L.), using
national cocoa varieties 800 and 801; and, to establish fruit, timber, biomass, musaceae and palm tree
crops, to optimize and generate value to the agroforestry systems.
Key words: cocoa, georeferenced coordinate, agroforestry systems, global positioning system.
http://centrosuragraria.com/index.php/revista, Published by: Edwards Deming Institute,
Quito - Ecuador, July - September vol. 1. Num. 14. 2022, This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons License, Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International.
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/deed.es
Received January 29, 2022
Approved: June 01, 2022
Verdezoto, Pino, Verdezoto 2022
July - September vol. 1. Num. 14 2022
Resumen
Existe escasa información de la superficie cultivada de cacao e inventario de especies en las fincas
agroforestales renovadas en la Unión de Organizaciones Campesinas Cacaoteras del Ecuador
(UNOCACE); esta investigación tuvo como propósito georreferenciar el área de los sistemas
agroforestales dinámicos en las fincas productoras de cacao nacional (Theobroma cacao L) e inventario
de la flora. Se utilizó el método de coordenada georreferenciada para determinar el área de la finca; y,
el sistema de posicionamiento global (GPS), para ubicar las especies que integran el sistema
agroforestal, utilizando para este caso las aplicaciones KoboCollect y GPS Status, descargados en un
dispositivo móvil inteligente (celular). Entre los años 2016 y 2017, los pequeños productores del recinto
“El Deseo”, instalaron 15 fincas, resultando un total de 11,8873 ha de sistemas agroforestales
dinámicos, siendo el rango de área desde 0,3 hasta 2,0 hectáreas. Los sistemas agroforestales evaluados,
presentan diferentes resultados de acuerdo con cada individuo, especie y familia que la componen. En
estos sistemas agroforestales, se recomienda complementar con cultivo de cacao (Theobroma cacao L.),
utilizando variedades de cacao nacional 800 y 801; y, establecer cultivos de frutales, maderables,
biomasa, musáceas y palmeras, para optimizar y generar valor a los sistemas agroforestales.
Palabras Clave: cacao, coordenada georreferenciada, sistemas agroforestales, sistema de
posicionamiento global.
Introduction
"The agroforestry system implies the rationalization of sustainability that occurs through an
adequate and integral management of the combination of each of its components tree, shrub
and fruit tree." (Caicedo & Amanda, 2021). "The association of cash crops with forest species
is important because they contribute to the conservation of soil, fertility and preserve water
sources that are indispensable for tree planting" (Intriago & Gortaire, 2018)..
"The advantage of agroforestry systems, lies in that: 1) helps soil conservation, prevents soil
erosion, increases micro and meso fauna, improves its texture and structure; 2) affects the
climate, decreasing wind speed and mortality in animals; 3) help retain moisture and reduce
evaporation from the soil; 4) influences frost by irradiation coming from the shrub layer; 5)
contributes to the protection of the atmosphere through the absorption of CO
2
that occurs
through the process of photosynthesis and increases water because it decreases
evapotranspiration; 6) protects biodiversity, as it becomes a refuge for birds, insects and other
beneficial animals; and, 7) produces economic income, with the sale of the products of
agricultural harvest, forestry and animal production." (Carbo, 2018).
"The disadvantage of agroforestry systems, occurs when: 1) too many trees or incompatible
species are implemented which can cause a decrease in crop production; 2) it can cause loss of
nutrients when wood and other forest products are harvested and exported outside the plot; 3)
the amount of water reaching the soil is reduced as it is intercepted by rain; 4) when trees are
98
harvested or pruned eventual mechanical damage to associated crops occurs, or also when
raindrops fall from tall trees; and, 5) trees can hinder mechanical harvesting on crops."
(Magnet, 2019).
"The diversified crop system is used to efficiently use the main agricultural area where different
species such as corn, bananas, plantains, cassava, timber trees or even implement animal
production, which improve soil nutrition and also contribute to the economy of small producers
until the cocoa crop begins to produce. Some of the advantages that can be obtained from
short-cycle crops are: 1) soil protection; 2) diversity of products (fruits, wood, firewood); 3)
increases the monetary income of farming families; 4) income is obtained throughout the year;
5) produces natural oxygen in such a way that it helps to conserve the environment; and, 6)
provides organic matter to the soil." (Intriago & Gortaire, 2018)..
"The cocoa crop has aspects very similar to a forest, so it is considered as an ecosystem created
by humans; however, its appearance will depend on the management provided by the producer
to it. There are several activities that affect its characteristics, such as the excessive use of
chemicals used in production, the presence of only one type of plant residue such as cocoa
leaves and inadequate management of irrigation water". (Imán, 2019).
"When biodiversity-friendly practices are employed, cocoa cultivation generates benefits such
as the recovery of habitats and ecosystems, protection of endangered species and improves the
connection between natural forests, where even endangered species find a refuge to develop.
A clear example of this is the native forest species or some bird species that are highly
endangered. The cultivation of cocoa guarantees the long-term sustainability of resources due
to the protection of water sources, soil and other associated ecosystems, raising the
conservation potential of a region that allows expanding areas of biodiversity." (Larrea, 2008).
According to Imán (2019), in agroforestry systems, soil management techniques should be used
to reduce erosion risks and maintain or improve soil fertility, meeting the following objectives:
1) protect the soil surface with vegetation cover to reduce the impact of sun and rain, and reduce
erosion risks; 2) maintain organic matter content in the surface soil strata to improve nutrient
and water retention; 3) sustain a shallow root system to conserve soil structure and absorb
nutrients found in the surface layer; 4) reduce the removal of organic matter and nutrients after
harvesting, i.e., plant residues should be left in the soil to provide organic matter and nutrients;
and, 5) reduce burning to avoid nutrient losses through volatilization and leaching.
"It is recommended to avoid establishing species that are not native and consume large
quantities of water, such as teak, tropical eucalyptus, African palm, etc. One of the native
species that consume large amounts of water is the laurel, so it should not be established near
the sources to be protected. In addition, it is recommended to establish species with superficial
Verdezoto, Pino, Verdezoto 2022
July - September vol. 1. Num. 14 2022
roots in greater quantity or density, so the shade will be greater and the loss of water by
evaporation will be lower" (Drouet et al, 2019).
"Diversification techniques is an economic and sustainable alternative that helps to increase
the quality of life in rural areas. Each territory can be identified by the various products by
establishing local development policies" (Perez et al, 2015).
A dynamic agroforestry system calculated for one hectare of cocoa cultivation and
recommended by the UNOCACE Farm Plus Project (2020) to all its associated producers,
consists of the following species:
Table 1 Dynamic agroforestry system
Species
Quantity / ha.
Planting distance (m.)
Cocoa
833
4 x 3
Fruit trees
8 x 9
Timber
8 x 9
Palms
15 x 15
Biomass (Guaba)
416
6 x 4
Musaceae
833
4 x 3
Source: Finca Plus Project, UNOCACE (2020).
"It is important to point out the species suitable for this cultivation system and the functions
of each one, where three species alternatives can be mentioned for the provinces of Guayas,
Esmeraldas and Sucumbíos " (Imán, 2019).
Table 2 Native fruit and timber species used for the edges and interior of the cocoa
agroforestry crop (Guayas, Los Ríos and Sucumbíos)
Fruit tree
Species
Forestry
Name
Common
Botanical Name
Name
Common
Noni
Ocotea acutifolia
Jigua
Papaya
Persea schiedeana
Aguacatillo
Borojó
Swietenia macrophylla
Mahogany
Araza
Centrolobium ochroxylum
Yellow
Handle
Guaiacum officinale
Guayacán
Marañon
Cedrela odorata
Cedar
Black sapote
Triplaris cumingiana Fisher
and Meyer
Fernán sanchez
Achotillo
Mongoose
Custard Apple
Mamey
Guaba
Caimito
Pomarrosa
Frutepan
Source: Mosquera (2021).
100
"In Ecuador there are several case studies of cocoa producers that determine that the practices
of productive diversification compared to monocultures present several benefits in the
economic, environmental, social and likewise for food sovereignty." (Carbo, 2018).
"Traditional and agro-diverse agriculture through the advance of the green revolution gave way
to productive specialization oriented to the market. The productive techniques implemented
in monoculture are not only related to the increased environmental impact of agriculture, but
also to the loss of economic autonomy of small farmers; therefore, the results presented in
economic and social terms of the diversification strategies used by small Ecuadorian cocoa
farmers are analyzed. The results of the different case studies show that farmers who intercrop
their cocoa plantations with other crops obtain better results in relation to monoculture. On the
other hand, diversification favors the informal exchange of products and in turn the
strengthening of social ties and affective networks" (Castillo et al. , 2018).
This study consists of characterizing the renewed agroforestry farms producing national cocoa
(Theobroma cacao, L.), in the Yaguachi canton, in the "El Deseo" area with producers
associated with UNOCACE, through a georeferencing of the various plant species, to help
improve agroforestry systems through the productive diversification of small producers, and
thus demonstrate the proper use of agroforestry systems found in each farm evaluated.
Materials and methods
The research was conducted in the Association of Agricultural Producers of El Deseo, "an
organization made up of more than 60 families dedicated to agricultural activity, located at km
26 of the Yaguachi canton in the province of Guayas, 15 minutes from the city of Milagro, with
its coordinates -S2° 12'6. 112" -W79° 37'39. 264" with an average altitude of 8 meters above
sea level" (Icaza et al., 2013). The method used to conduct the research was georeferenced
coordinates, in addition to the global positioning system (GPS) in the different agricultural
areas in which the KoBoCollect and GPS Status applications were used. Field activities
included identifying the farms and the work site, training the researchers by UNOCACE
technical staff, informing UNOCACE of the progress of the research and applying each
of the phases with the KoBoCollect and GPS Status applications. Different types of
applications were used to obtain the data for this study: 1) KoBoCollect application, which was
installed and configured on a smart mobile device; 2) GPS Status, used for the georeferencing
of the agroforestry systems; 3) tour of the perimeter of the farms to be evaluated, as
recommended by the UNOCACE Farm Plus Project (2020), to obtain the total area; 4) with the
Verdezoto, Pino, Verdezoto 2022
July - September vol. 1. Num. 14 2022
GPS Status and KoBoCollect application, opened on the smart cell phone, we proceeded to
georeference all the agroforestry species such as: cocoa, fruit trees, timber trees, musaceae,
biomass, species in regeneration present in each evaluated farm; 5) all the information obtained
in the field was recorded using a form in KoBoCollect. For the georeferencing in the case of
cocoa, it was necessary to stay completely close to the plant and take the GPS point. In
addition, for every 10 cocoa plants a sample had to be taken and determine whether the plant
was bifurcated or not, if it was bifurcated, a maximum of 3 bifurcations were taken, with the
help of a tape measure, the circumference diameters of each bifurcation and the height of the
plant were measured; 6) on a DBH (diameter at breast height) form, all the species located
such as musaceae, palms, timber, fruit trees, biomass, together with the GPS point were
recorded; 7) all the data were recorded on a form in KoBoCollect, to finish with all the
georeferencing of the species of each farm and then proceed to process the information; and,
8) all the results of the field work were interpreted.
Result
For the execution of this research, a georeferencing of the renewed agroforestry farms,
producers of national cocoa, which were installed in 2016 and 2017, was carried out; it was
necessary to go through the study area in order to measure the total area of the lots. It was
possible to obtain the necessary data, of which 12 farms were installed in 2016 and 3 farms in
2017, as shown in Table 3.
Table 3 Agroforestry farms producing national cocoa (Theobroma cacao, L.) evaluated in El
Deseo, Yaguachi canton, Guayas province.
Year
SAF NO.
Name of Producer
Area (ha.)
2016
01
05
06
08
Manuel Feliciano Salazar Beltran
Jacinto Velásquez Lavayen
Roberto Edmundo Martínez Maridueña
Juan Jofre Guerrero Reyes
Welcome to Perfecta Guerrero Peñafiel
Emilio Faustino León Ruíz
Lady Del Rosario Malavé Velásquez
Leonso Leonidas Martinez Salazar
María Estela Guerrero Peñafiel
Nancy Mónica Mora Salazar
Urbano Humberto Ruíz Franco
Víctor Daniel Haro León
0,5674
0,8878
0,5742
1,9675
1,0652
0,5118
0,7212
0,3927
0,8341
0,5621
0,7897
0,8559
Actual area taken
9,7296
102
Source: Association "El Deseo".
Prepared by: Authors.
Figure 1 shows the installation of agroforestry systems, where in 2016, 12 renewed agroforestry
farms producing national cocoa (Theobroma cacao, L.) were established; and, in 2017, 3 farms
were installed, belonging to small producers of the "El Deseo" precinct.
It is possible to observe the extension of the farms installed in 2016 and 2017, which present
certain variability in their surface range, oscillating from 0.3 to 2.0 hectares, which indicates
that it corresponds to the category of small producers; and, according to Prócel & Ordoñez
(2018), they say that a small producer is one who owns less than 5 ha.
Characterization of the agroforestry systems present in the farms evaluated.
The agroforestry systems evaluated in this study present variable results according to each
individual, species and family that compose it; a count of species planted in each area in the
evaluated farms has been made; in addition, according to sources recommended by the dynamic
agroforestry system of the UNOCACE Farm Plus Project (2020), the calculation allowed
making the relevant technical recommendations of the species that remain to be implemented
in the evaluated farms of the small national cocoa producers of the "El Deseo" precinct
associated with UNOCACE; this study agrees with the publication made by (Salvador et al.
2019), which states that the biological diversity of an agroforestry system can be measured
both by the richness of species and by the homogeneity of their distribution.
Characterization of the agroforestry system (SAF) N°01
The Agroforestry System (SAF) N°01, has an extension of 0.5674 ha, which was installed in
2016, which according to data reflected in Table 4, 200 individuals belonging to 14 species
have been determined, of which great floristic diversity can be determined; in this system the
cocoa species (Theobroma cacao, L.) stands out as one of the most important crops that
produces income to the peasant family economy; as a second crop of importance constitutes
the barraganete and dominico banana (Musa paradisiaca L.), established in greater numbers
than other species; and oak (Quercus robur L.), as one of the most important timber trees
established on the farm; according to (Guiracocha et al., 2001), agroforestry systems with
2017
Manuel Feliciano Salazar Beltran
Pedro Regalado Guerrero Reyes
Hobla León Suarez
0,5327
0,8681
0,7569
Actual area taken
2,1577
TOTAL AREA
11,8873
Verdezoto, Pino, Verdezoto 2022
July - September vol. 1. Num. 14 2022
cocoa, coffee and banana have the potential to be a fundamental tool for maintaining biological
diversity in their geographical environment.
Table 4 Agroforestry species identified in FFS N°01
Plant species
Scientific name
Family
Quantity
Achiote
Bixa orellana L.
Bixaceae
Cocoa
Theobroma cacao L.
Sterculiaceae
Coffee
Coffea arabica L.
Rubiaceae
1
Caimito
Chrysophylum cainito L.
Sapotaceae
1
Guaba
Inga edulis L.
Fabaceae
Guachapele
Albizia guachapele L.
Fabaceae
1
Mandarin lemon
Citrus limonia L.
Rutaceae
1
Handle
Mangifera indica L.
Anacardiaceae
Niguito
Muntingia calabura L.
Flacourtiaceae
1
Pachaco
Schizolobium parahybum
Caesalpinaceae
Banana barraganete
Musa paradisiaca L.
Musaceae
Dominican plantain
Musa paradisiaca L.
Musaceae
Oak
Quercus robur L.
Fogaceae
Tamarindo
Tamarindus indica L.
Fabaceae
1
Total, plant species
The items established in the SAF N°01, are catalogued as follows: cocoa (Theobroma cacao
L.); fruit trees such as caimito (Chrysophylum cainito, L.), mandarin lime (Citrus limonia L.),
mango (Mangifera indica L.), coffee (Coffea arabica L.), tamarind (Tamarindus indica L.);
timber species such as pachaco (Schizolobium parahybum), oak (Quercus robur L.),
guachapele (Albizia guachapele), niguito (Muntingia calabura L.); biomass such as achiote
(Bixa orellana L.) and guaba (Inga edulis L.); musaceae such as banana barraganete and
dominico (Musa paradisiaca L.).); and, it was identified that the farm does not have palm trees;
therefore, the farmer must necessarily plant this species on his farm; a study that agrees with
the publication by Guiracocha et al. (2001), where he states that the floristic structure of the
FFS are usually determined by fruit trees; while Sanchez & Sanchez (2016) and (Caicedo et al.
, 2019), indicate that the structure of the FFS are composed of timber and fruit trees; thus
originating "more carbon in long periods of time". (Alegre, 2017).
Technical proposal for PAS N°01
Taking into account the recommendation of the UNOCACE Dynamic Agroforestry Systems
Farm Plus Project (2020), the following table is proposed to optimize the number of
104
agroforestry species for this FFS, together with the species to be established on the farm
analyzed.
Table 5 Dynamic Agroforestry System recommended for PFS N°01
Species
C. Established
C. Recommended
Missing Species
Cocoa
473
334
Fruit trees
Timber
Palms
0
Biomass
236
223
Musaceae
473
448
Source: Finca Plus Project, UNOCACE (2020).
Prepared by: Authors.
The recommendation established for the SAF N°01, according to the calculated data presented
in Table 5, the farmer should establish in its 0.5674 ha, 334 national cocoa plants of the national
variety 800 and 801, 69 fruit trees (caimito, lemon, mandarin, mango, orange), 64 timber
species (pachaco, oak, guachapele, niguito), 25 palm trees (coconut, chontilla), 223 guaba and
achiote plants to recover the biomass; and 448 musaceous plants (banana barraganete,
dominico and guineo seda), so that the agroforestry system is dynamic, generates stable income
for the small producer, and is also environmentally friendly and compatible with the
environment.
The same procedure should be assumed for the following FFS N° 02 - 15, considering the area
(ha) of each farm and the number of plant species present in each agroforestry system, in order
to optimize each farm and make it profitable for the small cocoa producer; since the
biodiversity of the farm generates additional profits for the small producer and therefore the
biodiverse forest sequesters carbon and regulates the planet's climate, which is sometimes
invalidated by society. This same methodology and technology could be replicated on
smallholder cocoa farms in both the coastal and Amazonian regions of Ecuador, where
conventional inputs that degrade and pollute terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems are not used.
Conclusions
Between 2016 and 2017, 15 farms were installed, obtaining a result of 11.88 ha of dynamic
agroforestry systems. Of all the farms evaluated, the extension ranges from 0.3 to 2.0 hectares,
Verdezoto, Pino, Verdezoto 2022
July - September vol. 1. Num. 14 2022
which are located within the category of small producers. The purpose of the renovated
dynamic PFS is to improve the vegetation cover of the soil, to enhance family income, improve
the natural landscape and contribute to carbon recycling.
The main crops recorded on the 15 smallholder farms were classified as follows: cocoa
(Theobrama cacao L.), musaceae (Dominican plantain, guineo de seda and barraganete
plantain), biomass (guaba and achiote), fruit trees (guanabana, papaya, achotillo, orange,
mandarin, subtle lemon, mandarin lemon, grapefruit, guava, mamey colorado, mamey
cartagena, breadfruit), timber (oak, guachapele, pachaco, melina, cedar, laurel, guayacán) and
some palm trees (coconut, chontilla, African palm). The study revealed that there are several
farms that do not comply with the dynamic agroforestry systems recommended by
UNOCACE's Finca Plus Project (2020), and in most cases they need to be complemented with
the items already evaluated and in one or two cases apply a thinning system, so that the
agroforestry systems become profitable for the small producer, dynamic and environmentally
sustainable.
References
Alegre, J. (2017). Agroforestry in the Peruvian Amazon to recover degraded soils and mitigate
effects of Climate Change [Keynote speech]. XVI National and VII International
Congress of Soil Science "Soil breeding for good living". Ayacucho, Peru.
Caicedo, O., Díaz, O., Cadena, D., & Galarza, G. (2019). "Design of a sustainable rice
production system in Babahoyo, Los Ríos province, Ecuador." Killkana Técnica
Magazine, 19-24. Available at:
https://killkana.ucacue.edu.ec/index.php/killkana_tecnico/article/view/472.
Caicedo, R., & Amanda, J. (2021). Pruning and its effect on disease incidence in the cocoa
crop (Theobroma cacao L. ) produced in Ecuador. [Undergraduate Thesis, Universidad
Técnica de Babahoyo]. Available at: http://dspace.utb.edu.ec/handle/49000/9296.
Carbo, S. (2018). Socio-economic study of cocoa (Theobroma cacao L. ) cultivation in the
parish Febres Cordero, Canton Babahoyo Los Ríos-Ecuador [Tesis de Pregrado,
Universidad Técnica de Babahoyo]. Available at:
https://www.eumed.net/rev/oel/2019/02/cultivo-cacao-ecuador.html.
Castillo, M., Manuel, G., Morej, M., & Del Toto, O. (2018). "Soil conservation in farms with
Theobroma cacao, L. in the municipality of Baracoa". Man, Science and Technology
94-103. Available at: http://www.ciencia.gtmo.inf.cu/index.php/hct/article/view/853.
106
CELEC (2015). Flora Manual of the Baba Multipurpose area. Available at:
https://www.celec.gob.ec/hidronacion/images/PDF/gestion_ambiental/ambiental/man
ual-de-flora.pdf.
Drouet , A., Valarezo, O., Camacho, J., & García, G. (2019). "Sustainability promoters for
cacao (Theobroma cacao L.) agroforestry systems in Madre de Dios (Peru) and San
Placido (Ecuador)." UPSE Scientific and Technological Journal, (Volume 6) 76-81.
Available at: https://doi.org/10.26423/rctu.v6i2.478.
Guiracocha, G., Harvey, C., Somarriba, E., Krauss, U., & Carrillo, E. (2001). "Biodiversity
conservation in agroforestry systems with cacao and banana in Talamanca, Costa Rica."
Agroforestry in the Americas, 7-11. Available at:
https://repositorio.catie.ac.cr/handle/11554/5948.
Icaza, D., Pilozo, C., & Ormeño, M. (2013). Análisis para la creación de una microempresa
comercializadora de hierbabuena y albahaca de los pequeños productores en el recinto
el Deseo del cantón Yaguachi año 2012 [Pregrado Thesis, Universidad Estatal de
Milagro]. Available at: http://repositorio.unemi.edu.ec/handle/123456789/1373.
Imán, S. (2019). Manual of agronomic management of native cacao (Theobroma cacao L.)
cultivation in the Loreto region. National Institute for Agrarian Innovation [PDF file].
Available at: http://repositorio.inia.gob.pe/handle/20.500.12955/1065.
Intriago, R., & Gortaire, R. (2018). "Agroecology in Ecuador, Historical Process,
Achievements and Challenges." Agroecology, 95-103. Available at:
https://revistas.um.es/agroecologia/article/view/330131.
Larrea, M. (2008). The cultivation of Cacao Nacional: a generous forest. Field manual for the
implementation of biodiversity-friendly practices in Cacao Nacional crops. Programa
Nacional Biocomercio Sostenible. Quito, Ecuador. Available at:
http://cadenacacaoca.info/CDOC-
Deployment/documentos/El_cultivo_de_cacao_Nacional,_un_bosque_generoso.pdf.
Mosquera, B. (2021). Economic importance of organic cocoa (Theobroma cacao) in Ecuador
[Undergraduate Thesis, Universidad Técnica de Babahoyo]. Available at:
http://dspace.utb.edu.ec/handle/49000/9226.
Verdezoto, Pino, Verdezoto 2022
July - September vol. 1. Num. 14 2022
Pérez, G., Chimborazo, C., & Freile, J. (2015). "In situ characterization of cocoa morphological
variability". Revista Amazónica Ciencia y Tecnología, 146-165. Available at:
https://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/articulo?codigo=5292891 .
Prócel, D., & Ordoñez, A. (2018). The dependence of small agrifood producers on value chains
and its effects on climate vulnerability [Master's Thesis, Universidad Andina Simón
Bolívar]. Available at: https://repositorio.uasb.edu.ec/handle/10644/6439.
Salvador, P., Del Carmen, L., Martínez, J., Sánchez, R., & Valdés, E. (2019). "Diversity,
structure and carbon of tree vegetation in cocoa agroforestry systems. Timber and
Forests." Timber and Forests, 1-14. Available at:
https://doi.org/10.21829/myb.2019.2511638.
Sánchez, J., & Sánchez, K. (2016). Analysis of the influence of the processes of the productive
matrix in the commercialization of cocoa of the producers of the recinto la inmaculada
del cantón Yaguachi, 2015-2016. [Undergraduate thesis, Universidad Estatal de
Milagro]. Available at: http://repositorio.unemi.edu.ec//handle/123456789/2824.
UNOCACE. (2020). Interview with Steven León & Lenín Robayo (Finca Plus Project
Technicians) / Interviewed by Victor Verdezoto.